Auction vs Private Sale: An Insight into Pricing Variances of Fine Instruments

Historically, the auctioning of fine instruments has been a domain reserved for insiders—experts, luthiers, and seasoned collectors with specialised knowledge in the field of string instruments. These industry professionals were adept at navigating the complexities of the auction world, willing to take calculated risks on certain instruments which, with the right care, restoration, or authentication, could be transformed into valuable pieces of their collections or inventories. This scenario has undergone a significant shift in recent years, leading to a broader discussion on the dynamics of violin pricing at auctions versus dealer or maker prices.

The Evolving Auction Landscape

In the past, auctions served as a specialised marketplace where the stakes of buying and selling were understood and accepted by those involved. Participants were typically well-versed in the nuances of instrument quality, provenance, and the potential costs of restoration or certification. The gamble was calculated, with industry insiders possessing the skills and knowledge to make informed decisions about the instruments on offer.

However, the allure of auctions has broadened their appeal beyond this niche community. The apparent transparency of the auction process and the perceived value of being able to acquire instruments potentially below the traditional market price have attracted a new wave of participants. This includes students, amateur players, and enthusiasts who, despite their passion and interest in string instruments, may lack the specialised knowledge traditionally associated with auction participants.

The apparent transparency of the auction process and the perceived value of being able to acquire instruments potentially below the traditional market price have attracted a new wave of participants.

The Consequences of a Broadened Audience

This shift towards a more inclusive auction audience has had several implications for the market:

1. Increased Risk of Costly Mistakes: Without the deep understanding of instrument valuation, condition assessment, and the intricacies of restoration, new entrants into the auction market are more susceptible to making costly mistakes. They may overestimate the value of an instrument based on incomplete information or underestimate the significance of proper authenticity and condition assessment, leading to purchases that do not meet their expectations or require unforeseen additional investments.
2. Misinterpretation of Catalogue Descriptions: The complex language of auction catalogues, with terms defining the condition, provenance, and authenticity of instruments, can be challenging to navigate without specialized knowledge. Terms like "Attributed to," "Circle of," "Composite" etc; carry specific meanings within the industry that may not be fully appreciated by newer participants, leading to misjudgements in the value and potential of the instruments up for auction.
3. Fees and overbidding: The buyer's premium, typically around 20%, adds a substantial amount to the hammer price. Buyers must remain cognizant of the fact that their total investment can escalate beyond the initial budget, especially in the heat of a bidding war. This scenario can lead to a situation where the buyer, in pursuit of a desired instrument, ends up significantly overstretched financially. Additional outlays such as taxes, tariffs, and transportation costs—expenses that are rarely absorbed by the auction house—can significantly increase the total cost of acquisition.
4. Changing Market Dynamics: The influx of less experienced buyers has the potential to alter market dynamics, with increased demand leading to higher prices for certain instruments which might look appealing, regardless of their actual condition or authenticity. This can result in a market where the price at auction does not accurately reflect the instrument's true value, complicating the landscape for all participants

Without the deep understanding of instrument valuation, condition assessment, and the intricacies of restoration, new entrants into the auction market are more susceptible to making costly mistakes.

Understanding these nuances is crucial for buyers to ensure they make informed decisions that reflect the true value and cost of acquiring an instrument through auction.

The Enduring Value of a Trusted Dealer

In navigating the complexities of the fine instrument market, the partnership with a reliable and respected dealer emerges as a crucial element in securing not just a transaction, but a worthwhile investment in one's musical journey.

It is true that opinions on the trustworthiness of certain dealers in the market for high-quality instruments vary. Some musicians believe they have been unfairly treated, paying overly high prices due to what they perceive as the dealers' excessive profit motives. This sentiment, while not universal, highlights the importance of caution and due diligence when selecting a dealer to work with. Despite these concerns, the value of establishing a relationship with a trusted dealer cannot be overstated. A reputable dealer not only offers transparent pricing but also brings invaluable expertise in assessing the quality, authenticity, and provenance of fine instruments. This relationship ensures that buyers and sellers receive fair treatment and that the instruments in question are presented and valued accurately. Furthermore, a trusted dealer provides ongoing support, advice, and access to a network of musicians and collectors, enriching the overall ownership experience. In navigating the complexities of the fine instrument market, the partnership with a reliable and respected dealer emerges as a crucial element in securing not just a transaction, but a worthwhile investment in one's musical journey.

To this effect, and in contrast to the shifting sands of the auction market, the best dealers offer a stable and informed environment for the purchase and sale of fine violins. Their expertise provides a safeguard against the risks inherent in auction participation. Dealers not only ensure the quality and authenticity of the instruments they sell but also offer buyers the opportunity to compare different violins side by side, making an informed choice based on sound, playability, and personal preference.

A trusted dealer offers a more stable and reliable environment for buying and selling fine violins, which is reflected in their pricing:

1. Authentication and Verification: Dealers provide expert assessments of an instrument's condition, authenticity, and provenance, akin to a detailed home inspection in real estate. This service reassures buyers, justifying the typically higher prices found in dealerships compared to the more variable outcomes of auctions.
2. Opportunity for Comparison: Unlike auctions, dealers allow buyers to try and compare different instruments over time in a controlled environment. This ability to directly assess the nuances between violins ensures a more informed purchase decision, often leading buyers to value the expertise and personalised service offered by dealerships.
3. Market Knowledge: A trusted dealer possesses extensive knowledge of the current market, enabling them to price instruments more accurately based on their intrinsic qualities and the broader market demand. This expertise promotes price stability and fairness, distinguishing dealers from the more volatile auction market.

Auction Prices for Contemporary Violin Makers

When it comes to contemporary instruments, inexperienced or ill-advised sellers can sometimes turn to auctions without realising the intricacies involved in establishing a maker's reputation and demand within the auction world. This lack of awareness can lead to significantly low public auction prices, which, if were to become the norm, would make it unsustainable for any craftsman to continue their trade. Additionally, the auction scene for contemporary instruments often misses its mark with the most passionate collectors and buyers, who typically do not seek out contemporary pieces in such settings. This exclusion from the biggest buyer pool further diminishes the chances of achieving a fair price, underscoring the importance of a more strategic approach to selling these instruments. Direct sales through reputable dealers or directly from the makers themselves not only help in sustaining the craft but also ensure that contemporary instruments are matched with those who value and seek them, fostering a healthier market for the makers' artistry and dedication.

(...)the auction scene for contemporary instruments often misses its mark with the most passionate collectors and buyers, who typically do not seek out contemporary pieces in such settings.

When it Comes to Selling Your Instrument

Most individuals who purchase an instrument at auction would hesitate to select the same avenue for selling it if their goal is to maximise their investment. This preference underscores the significance of maintaining a relationship with a trusted dealer. A dealer not only provides a more controlled and knowledgeable environment for the initial purchase but also represents a strategic partner for the future resale of the instrument. Unlike the unpredictable nature of auctions, where numerous factors beyond the seller's control can significantly impact the selling price, a reputable dealer has a vested interest in helping you resell your instrument. They leverage the same benefits that attracted you as a buyer—expertise in valuation, a broad network of potential buyers, and the ability to present the instrument in its best condition. This partnership with a dealer ensures that when the time comes to sell, your investment is positioned to achieve its maximum potential value, benefiting from a tailored approach that auctions simply cannot offer.

When the time comes to sell, your investment is positioned to achieve its maximum potential value, benefiting from a tailored approach that auctions simply cannot offer.

Conclusion

In sum, while private sale prices may appear higher at first glance, they reflect a comprehensive value proposition that encompasses not just the instrument itself but also the suite of services and assurances that accompany a dealer purchase. The seemingly lower prices at auction, when viewed in light of the total costs and risks involved, may ultimately come at a higher cost, both financially and in terms of peace of mind. This analysis underscores the importance of considering all factors in the buying and selling process, ensuring that decisions are made with a full understanding of the true costs and value involved.

‍